Informal Assessment vs. Formal Assessment:
Informal asssessments are
very often just based on classroom observation. When the students get
involved in something that they are enjoying they won't even notice that
you are gauging their abilities. Playing games
like Jeopardy or creating your own individual fun games can really give
you a sense of where your students are at. Formal assessments are the
tests that sometimes have to be administered but no one likes to take.
Be very clear as to what the test is going to
be on but don't just give a study guide that can be memorized and
regurgitated. I will give a study guide but it will be on concepts that
they should know and not very fine-tuned ideas.
Paper-Pencil Assessment vs. Performance Assessment:
I would make use of paper
pencil assessments when I need to know quick things and want to hear
from everybody. After reading our story for the week, have every one
pull out a piece of paper and write down what they
comprehended from the story. You could even ask a couple of questions.
Performance assessment would just be asking questions aloud that the
students could respond with the answers out loud. It sometimes give you
less of an idea of the comprehension because
you can't ask every single student.
Standardized Test vs. Teacher Developed Assessment:
Standardized tests for
elementary students in Tennessee are tests that include the TCAPS. Using
the information gathered in these tests, it is very useful in gauging
how well you have done as a teacher. It is not good
for administering any grades that matter but maybe in viewing trends in
your classes result and knowing concepts you can work on (while not
teaching to the test... that is a no no!) Teacher-developed assessments
are going to be pretty much everything you adminster
from informal to formal assessments. They include written test, oral
reports, and portfolios. As a teacher I hope to administer most of these
during the year so all students who may struggle at one assessment but
excel at another have an equal chance of excelling
in class.
Criterion-referenced assessment vs. Norm-referenced assessment:
Criterion-referenced in my class might include multiple choice tests over the solar system. There are only one right answer for each question, you must know your material, and the percentage of what you get right is how you come out on your final grade. Norm-reference might examine reading comprehension which is a little harder to grade on a percentage level and see how their knowledge compared to their classmates.
Traditional Assessment vs. Authentic Assessment
Traditional assessment may be the least fun way to test students but sometimes the only way to truly know every students abilities in a subject. Pop quizzes, planned unit tests, or even fact table quizzes is the traditional way to gauge students ability. Authentic assessment is when one looks at the knowledge the student should have acquired and respond with something that can be fun and engaging and natural step in learning. If a student is learning in science about different types of ecosystems, have them make a diorama that incorporates all the characteristics of that ecosystem to test their understanding.
I really like how you were able to use each different assessment in an example without biased against the other assessment. I fully believe that there is a time, place, and reason for each type of assessment.
ReplyDeleteMost of the time I don’t make comments on websites, but I'd like to say that this article really forced me to do so. Really nice post!
ReplyDeleteHbse